29 Comments
User's avatar
Rita Ott Ramstad's avatar

Where I grew up, at the end of our block was woods. If you walked through them, about a mile or maybe a little more, you'd get to the beach. There was a clearing partway there. That was my first thin place. Not water, but proximity to it. The promise of it.

How lucky you are, and I once was, to live where thin places are plentiful.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Thank you, Rita. Thin places are everywhere, but sometimes they are really well hidden. I hope you find some.

Expand full comment
Antonia Malchik's avatar

I remember that interview with O'Donahue! I'd forgotten about it. I should go listen again.

What a lovely encounter. Thank you for sharing this.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Thanks, Nia. You might recognize a confluence of comment conversations here. They are the best writing prompts!

Expand full comment
Ernest Craige's avatar

Great post, John.

For me, the transcendent place was a monastery in the mountains. Your post helped me recall what happened. That event eventually led me to Whidbey.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

That's so interesting to hear. Many have been drawn to Whidbey by a similar pull, in some cases, like my own, while thinking they were looking for something else!

Expand full comment
Douglas Adamson's avatar

John

I love the description a ‘thin place.’ It is good to recall those magical moments when a landscape or place transports you into another private dimension. I have had a few in my life, mostly in the Highlands or Scotland.

I had one on the island of Iona. Rising up a small incline on a sunny day, cresting the rise suddenly I was greeted by a view of the sea which was deepest blue, shimmering, and astonishing, unexpected in its other worldly beauty.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Scotland was the home of my paternal ancestors. Something about it has always called me.

Expand full comment
Freya Rohn's avatar

How funny that I similarly thought of a time in Iona as I read. Those islands!

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

What a beautiful memory, especially with the added appreciation you've found for it over time. I'm impressed with the way you took a fresh prompt and brought it around to your water-theme. :-)

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Water works its way into everything! Thank you Tara.

Expand full comment
Ann Linnea's avatar

There have been numerous thin places in my life—most often camping trips in the high mountains or on big water. But moving to Whidbey Island many decades ago opened the door to a number of "thin" places and people who recognize and share such a phenomenon. Thank you for this, John. Ann

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

We are so blessed.

Expand full comment
Mark Malinak's avatar

The “Thin Places” for me are the tall crowns of the white pines swaying and ringing in the breeze, the deep blue spring sky framing the entrance to the eternal. I stand in stillness and quiet feeling myself carried effortlessly into the heights above. This is the gathering of pines that surrounds my wife’s burial cairn in the forest of our home. In those moments , I become these upper most branches stretching, reaching…enraptured. And the wind that enfolds and caresses my arms is my wife at play, my wife in a fury of reckless love.

Thank you, John. I also held John O’Donohue close to me during those first years. Still do.

Expand full comment
Deb Sinness's avatar

Scotland’s Isle of Skye is my thin place.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

I haven't been, but an island on a western shore prechecks several thin place boxes!

Expand full comment
Prison Chronicles's avatar

Your voice is so soothing, haha! Great content can’t wait to go through it all

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Thank you so much!

Expand full comment
Lindsey Melden's avatar

What a lovely story, and I’m so glad you found the language for your “thin place” - I too love that interview with John Odonohue. 💗

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Thank you, Lindsey. To thin places!

Expand full comment
Jen🧚's avatar

My first time to encounter the term "Thin Places". I have to check it out.

Also, I was amazed with the names in this post - I cannot pronounce a lot of them.

Expand full comment
Timber Fox's avatar

I've been to Inishmor and Skellig Michael, and those isles are affecting. Thank you for sharing your story!

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

Thank you for reading. There's something about islands.

Expand full comment
Douglas Adamson's avatar

It was St Columba’s abbey on Iona that affected me most. I have never visited a place with such an overwhelming sense of tranquility. It is truly spiritual whatever your religion may be.

Expand full comment
Freya Rohn's avatar

I love happening upon those moments that we don't have language for, that inexplicably move us by something powerful--and then how beautiful to find the language from O'Donahue and knowing exactly the moment that you have experienced it. And how it shapes our lives in different ways, both small and large, with your Island-dwelling heart not letting you live without the sea around you.

And I do think there is something powerful about those islands. I had a similar experience on Iona, unexpectedly, because I had gone to see the place of Colum Cille as a grad student living in Scotland and researching early medieval Celtic history, and the viewed the rather hippy community there at the time with lofty, snobby judgement. The place had something more to tell me and I will never forget the beauty of that place. 💜

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

The concept of Thin Place is from the "Celtic fringe", the western sides of Britain and Ireland, of which those islands are part. An urge to go west, to the western shore of wherever I am, has been another force in my life. More to unpack...

Expand full comment
Logan Darrow's avatar

I love islands - there is something magical about them. I've lived on a couple, one east coast US, one west coast. I always thought I would live on one permanently but hasn't worked out that way.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

You've found a beautiful spot.

Expand full comment